Share this article:

The Secret HR Director: HR for HR's Sake - are your initiatives worthwhile?

We’re delighted to introduce our latest contributor, The Secret HR Director. Each month our undercover operator, who has worked for some of the world’s largest organisations, will speak out on the biggest issues in HR that many in the industry simply sweep under the carpet.

As the first month of the year draws to a close, many in HR will be putting in place new strategies they hope will make a splash. But how many are lacking the substance to make a difference?

If there’s something many people in senior HR roles like doing, it’s an initiative.  Rolling out an employee engagement initiative.  A new performance review system.  Going for best places to work award.

But how much of this is for them and how much is for the organisation? 

HR is an overhead.  Bad HR is a cost.  You don’t want your department to be referred to as “blockers”, “pointless” or “human remains”.  So this is where the initiatives come in.  You can garner peer approval and win awards with these initiatives – and then you prove that HR is doing the right thing in your organisation.

A new HR Director might enter a company with bold promises of getting it into the Best Companies to Work For.  That becomes the focus, and creates many more initiatives – which involve lots of fun awaydays, focus groups and “engagement activities”.  The department name is changed from HR to People.

Ok, the pay and reward system is wasting millions, the attrition rates are sky high . . . . but here is something that the CEO can understand, and the HRD will get their name in lights – and a whopping great big bonus when it happens (or article in an HR publication, at the very least). 

However, tempting it is to do these sexy initiatives, gain lots of praise from peers and some great stuff on the CV for your next job, is part of the role of the HRD to be less focused on HR but on what the business actually needs?

That’s not to say I don’t love a good initiative.  Now, where is that flip chart?

Comments (2)

Sign up for a FREE myGrapevine account to have your say.

  • Geraldine Buckland
    Geraldine Buckland
    Tue, 23 Jun 2015 10:21pm BST
    I've worked for and with many organisations and I've seen many iterations of image over substance. Some individuals are adept at doing little and getting all the accolades, because they do the right things, the high profile things: they get their name in lights. A good "initiative" or a shiny badge is the classic route. But it's not only the HRD who's good at this game. It can be played from any seat in the organisation. Great fun to watch it playing out though, don't you think? It impacts on different people in so many different ways. Only a genuine performance culture is immune to this - in my opinion. LIKE YOUR BLOG IDEA BTW
  • Sian Vernon
    Sian Vernon
    Thu, 29 Jan 2015 3:49pm GMT
    Something very wrong with both the CEO an HRD in your scenario. If what HR delivers doesn't directly connect to and impact on the core strategic objectives of the Company, then it has no place in the business
  • Sean Durrant
    Sean Durrant
    Thu, 29 Jan 2015 1:07pm GMT
    I think like all initiatives they need to be valid, but most of all supported by the management team.
Share this article: