Retiring employee accidentally emails entire office ruthless exit statement

Retiring employee accidentally emails entire office ruthless exit statement

We’ve all had a slip of the tongue at work – whether that’s revealing too much about what happened at the weekend, or accidentally sending a funny image to the wrong person.

However, one worker may have made one of the most mortifying mistakes, by sending the entire company an email relaying his opinion of his bosses.

Michael Stuban, 58, a Manager at the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission, was about to retire after his 35-year career.

Before he left, he was given an exit questionnaire which included questions about salary, benefits and any improvements or suggestions he had for the company.

Stuban was brutally honest in the written comments section, which he accidentally sent to all 2000 employees at the Turnpike Commission.

He wrote: “I really didn’t want to retire yet. I like my job. The first 30 years were great but the last five years are terrible.”

Then he got down to the nitty-gritty, stating: “We have no morale, I feel the PTC is rudderless, that executive-level management is out of touch with average employees, only looking out for themselves.”

When asked about the frustrations he had, he wrote: “Giving us classes where we are being told we are not political. That’s bull****. Jobs/Promotions are filled by the politicians, it’s who you know, not what you know. Positions created for people who are not qualified.”

He also suggested a few changes: “Get rid of unqualified employees (I know that’s a dream, they have political connections or are someone’s relative.)

He explained to the Philly Inquirer, (through occasional chuckles) about his ruthless response:  "When they asked for an honest exit interview, I gave them one. I sent it minutes before I officially retired."

He added that one of the biggest problems at the agency is political patronage, where relatives of powerful people get hired regardless of their competence.

"They hire a lot of people that are dumb as rocks," he said.

Despite his frankness about the negative aspects, Stuban did also give a balanced view of his tenure, writing in his note: “I don’t feel any other position would be better than my position on the PTC. I liked my job and was thankful to have it.”

However, Sean Logan, Chairman of the Turnpike Commission, who received the email, was not impressed. He replied to all and wrote: "Mr. Stuban . . . I don't believe we ever met, and after reading your exit questionnaire, I am grateful that we didn't."

This case highlights the importance of the exit interview.

Recently, we spoke to Liza Bennigson, Business Development Director at KonnectAgain, who said the exit interview process need a radical makeover; departing staff should be good brand ambassadors, while their new employer could be a potential client. To read the full article, click here.

Have you enjoyed this piece?

Subscribe now to myGrapevine+ and get access to exclusive new content, and the full content archive.

Be the first to comment.

You are currently previewing this article.

This is the last preview available to you for 30 days.

To access more news, features, columns and opinions every day, create a free myGrapevine account.