Share this article:

'Irreparable harm' | Judge halts health service layoffs, calling the move unlawful

Robert F Kennedy Jr. black and white

A federal court has intervened in the Trump administration’s plan to downsize the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), granting a preliminary injunction that blocks layoffs and a major reorganization of the federal agency.

The order, issued by Judge Melissa DuBose, comes in response to a lawsuit filed by attorneys general representing 19 states and the District of Columbia. In her ruling, DuBose stated that the plaintiffs demonstrated “irreparable harm” from the March layoffs and were likely to succeed in showing that “HHS’s action was both arbitrary and capricious as well as contrary to law.”

“The executive branch does not have the authority to order, organize, or implement wholesale changes to the structure and function of the agencies created by Congress,” DuBose wrote.

The ruling requires HHS to pause finalizing any previously announced layoffs and prohibits further terminations. The department must submit a status report by July 11.

Four divisions face workforce freeze

The injunction applies to employees across four divisions of HHS: the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; the Center for Tobacco Products at the Food and Drug Administration; the Office of Head Start within the Administration for Children and Families and related regional staff; and the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation.

In March, Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. had ordered layoffs impacting more than 10,000 workers and moved to consolidate 28 agencies into 15 under the “Make America Healthy Again” initiative. Kennedy later testified before Congress that the department was plagued by “so much chaos and disorganization.”

Since the announcement, agencies including the CDC have rescinded hundreds of layoff notices, some in disease monitoring units focused on HIV and hepatitis.

Featured Resource

What Really Drives Employee Engagement? The Six-Pillar Framework

What Really Drives Employee Engagement? The Six-Pillar Framework

Half of the workforce is so dissatisfied that they're actively looking for new opportunities.

A lack of engagement, workplace culture, well-being, and work-life balance are among the biggest challenges facing organisations today. And while many businesses invest in multiple employee initiatives, a collection of disconnected programs won't stop people from leaving. The answer isn't more employee engagement initiatives - it's ensuring your strategy is built on a coherent, evidence-based model that addresses the factors that matter most.

Within this report you can explore: 

  • The six foundational pillars of employee engagement that drive stronger retention, productivity, and business performance.

  • Practical strategies for applying each pillar to build a high-impact employee engagement programme.

  • A framework for aligning engagement with business goals to create a more motivated, committed, and high-performing workforce.

Download the report today and discover how to build an employee engagement strategy that drives meaningful engagement, boosts retention, and improves performance.

Show more
Show less

States claim public health is at risk

The lawsuit says that the restructuring overreached HHS’s authority and imposed financial and operational burdens on the states. “The intended effect … was the wholesale elimination of many HHS programs that are critical to public health and safety,” the plaintiffs argued.

States with Democratic governors brought the case, arguing the action would damage essential services including food and drug regulation, tobacco control, and maternal and infant health programs. Many of the same states also brought a separate case over $11 billion in public health funding cuts, which also resulted in a preliminary injunction in May.

Kennedy, a controversial and divisive pick as Health Secretary, has acknowledged that “mistakes” occurred during the reorganization and indicated that 20% of those laid off may be reinstated.

Be the first to comment.

Sign up for a FREE myGrapevine account to have your say.

Share this article:

You are currently previewing this article.Create account

This is the last preview available to you for the next 30 days.

To receive our daily newsletter and access HR features & insights, create a free account today.