'Who told you?' | Boss-employee argument over pay transparency goes viral, but why is it still a taboo?

Boss-employee argument over pay transparency goes viral, but why is it still a taboo?

A recent heated exchange between a worker and her boss over pay transparency has ignited a broader conversation about the secrecy surrounding salaries in the workplace.

The incident, which unfolded in Australia, encapsulates the ongoing tension between employees seeking fair compensation and employers reluctant to disclose wage information.

In the viral exchange, shared by Yahoo Finance from a Mumsnet thread, a worker named Christina confronted her manager, Elliot, after discovering she was the lowest-paid staff member in the team, regardless of her long tenure and seniority.

"I found out I’m the lowest paid on the team. That is despite the fact I have been here the longest and [am] also one of the most senior,” she wrote.

“Hi Christina, who told you that?” the boss replied.

Following a heated back and forth, the boss added that pay was "not an appropriate topic of discussion for the workplace”, to which Christina pushed back and continued to discuss the pay disparity.

Only when Christina threatened to quit did the boss relent saying he'd "find the money”. "Consider it done," he concluded.

Why is pay transparency still a rampant issue?

At the heart of the issue is a fundamental imbalance of power.

When employees lack access to information about their colleagues' salaries, they are left vulnerable to exploitation and discrimination. Disparities in pay based on gender, race or seniority often go unchecked, contributing to broader systemic inequalities within the workforce.

The reluctance to discuss salaries not only undermines individual employees' bargaining power, but also hinders efforts to address larger societal issues, such as the persistent gender pay gap.

Without transparency, it becomes nearly impossible to identify and rectify instances of unequal pay, leaving marginalised groups at a distinct disadvantage.

It’s also true that a lack of transparency fosters a culture of secrecy and mistrust within organisations.

Employees who suspect they are being underpaid may feel reluctant to speak up for fear of retaliation or backlash. This silence perpetuates a cycle of inequity, where those in positions of power retain control over salary negotiations while others are left in the dark.

To combat this entrenched problem, organisations must take proactive steps to promote pay transparency as a core value.

This begins with openly discussing the benefits of transparency and debunking common myths and misconceptions surrounding salary disclosure.

Employees should have access to transparent salary bands and criteria for advancement, allowing them to gauge their own worth within the organisation.

Additionally, regular audits and reviews of salary structures can help identify and address disparities before they escalate into larger issues.



You are currently previewing this article.

This is the last preview available to you for the next 30 days.

To access more news, features, columns and opinions every day, create a free myGrapevine account.