Pay no longer motivates executives, finds LSE & PwC study
Published: by
by

Executives would be happier being paid a smaller salary in a less complex and volatile form, according to new research.

A study of over 1,100 executives by PwC in conjunction with the London School of Economics and Political Science, suggests that many aspects of current incentive plans don’t motivate the executives they are aimed at.

According to the research, deferred bonuses hold little incentive, with the majority of executives valuing £100 of bonus in a typical deferral plan at only half its value. This discount is massively in excess of economic discount rates and the perceived value drops to as low as £33 for younger employees (those under the age of 39).

Complex and uncertain incentives are also undesirable. 51% of respondents favoured a cash plan based on profit targets that they understand over a more ambiguous share plan based on their share price relative to other companies. The more complicated the reward, the more likely participants were to choose the smaller but more certain reward.

The research also suggests that executives are concerned about the perceived fairness of pay. For over half (51%) of respondents , getting paid more than their peers was more important than getting paid more in absolute terms (27%). While many countries are calling for greater disclosure on pay, the research suggests the opposite, with executives concerned that this will provide more opportunities for cross-comparisons.

Tom Gosling, Head of PwC’s Reward Practice says: "UK executive pay is based on the motivational theory that loading executives up with large amounts of incentive pay with complex performance conditions means that they’ll perform better for shareholders. Unfortunately this isn’t supported by our study, which shows that complex pay plans are a motivation killer. The more complex the pay, the lower the value in executives’ eyes.

 “We need to simplify pay significantly. We’ve tried to put too much of the package into complex incentives that executives don’t value, and this is leading to volatility of pay-outs and unintended consequences. If we had simpler, less volatile pay plans then most executives would be happy to be paid less.”

 

|Comments (1)| Comment
Mon, 21 May 2012 12:25pm BST
Chris Garner
Motivational theory does not say this. In fact it says if it's too complex to understand the link between effort and reward then it wont motivate. We knew this decades ago!
+ Read more...
- Show less
Related Stories
Remuneration rules acting as ‘restraining hand’ on boardroom bonuses
Remuneration rules acting as 'restraining hand' on boardroom bonuses says EY
New government regulations are acting as a ‘restraining hand’ on boardroom pay and bonuses according to a new report... read more ›
Fathers earn significantly more than men without children
Fathers earn significantly more than men without children
It may be better for men to start their own family as fathers made 40% more than childless men in 2010, according to research from The Graduate Center... read more ›
Directors 'earn 120 times more than average worker'
Directors 'earn 120 times more than average worker'
Directors of the top 100 listed UK companies now earn 120 times more than their average employee, according to a report by Incomes Data Services (IDS)... read more ›
Deutsche Bank withhold bonuses
Deutsche Bank withhold bonuses
Deutsche Bank is withholding millions of euros in bonuses from its co-chief executives and other current and former top managers as it seeks to hold senior staff accountable for a host of costly legal and regulatory problems... read more ›
Gender pay gap in accounting still prominent
Gender pay gap in accounting still prominent
More than a third of accountants (37%) in the UK believe that men are paid more than women doing the same job in their industry, according to the new research... read more ›
UK makes last-ditch effort to overturn EU bonus cap ruling
UK makes last-ditch effort to overturn EU bonus cap ruling
The Treasury is preparing for a clash with EU in an effort to overturn the cap imposed on bankers’ bonuses... read more ›
Employee Facebook monitoring set to rise
Employee Facebook monitoring set to rise
Online monitoring in the office will rise over the next decade as the presence of Generation Y increases... read more ›
'Mid-life pay crisis' for female managers
'Mid-life pay crisis' for female managers
Women over 40 are earning more than a third less than men according to a new salary figures... read more ›